https://x.com/CBSSportsCBB/status/2014796825249644587?t=QiqNeECLMzltXvz44eZV9g&s=19
Agree or disagree?
Quote from: WILD on January 23, 2026, 02:09:35 PMhttps://x.com/CBSSportsCBB/status/2014796825249644587?t=QiqNeECLMzltXvz44eZV9g&s=19
Agree or disagree?
Sean Elliot HAS to be in there. Sorry Richard
Channing Frye, or Sean Rooks over Ayton, anyday.
Quote from: wc on January 23, 2026, 02:30:11 PMChanning Frye, or Sean Rooks over Ayton, anyday.
Deandre averaged over 20 and 11. Frye and Rooks don't come close, but they were part of better teams. I'd have to agree and have Ayton in my all time starting 5. He was an absolute monster
PG: Mike Bibby
SG: Damon Stoudamire
SF: Sean Elliott
PF: Derrick Williams
C: DeAndre Ayton
6th man: Gilbert Arenas
Tj McConnell
Miles Simon
Sean Elliott
D-Will
Channing Frye
2nd team:
Bibby
Arenas
Budinger
Jefferson
Gordon
Damon Stoudemire
Khalid Reeves
Sean Elliott
Brian Willaims (Bison Dele)
DeAndre Ayton
Damon Stoudamire
Steve Kerr
Luke Walton
Sean Elliott
DeAndre Ayton
This group, for me, has all the attributes I'd want as my Top 5
Nico Mannion + anybody else
Damon chimes in 👀
https://x.com/Iambiggie503/status/2014900775231574143?t=ncBRwenH7h5k_VB0p5DBrA&s=19
Quote from: WILD on January 24, 2026, 07:14:26 PMDamon chimes in 👀
https://x.com/Iambiggie503/status/2014900775231574143?t=ncBRwenH7h5k_VB0p5DBrA&s=19
Damon is accurate, but one must take into account that Rothstein knows he needs to rage bait. So his list is skewed on purpose.
A lot of better Top 5's that make more sense in this thread.
It's hard to lot include either Stoudemire. Salim was the purest shooter in college basketball history and Damon ran the show better than anybody.
Quote from: KansasCityCats on January 25, 2026, 07:40:02 AMIt's hard to lot include either Stoudemire. Salim was the purest shooter in college basketball history and Damon ran the show better than anybody.
That is one of the reasons why it is to difficult for me to come up with a five because there are too many guards to choice from.
Thus the nickname, Point Guard U!
My top 5, and my favorite 5 would be different, but if I followed their college careers?
Bibby
Arenas
Elliott
Williams
Ayton
Then you would have the rest of the names that I considered when thinking about my five:
Bayless
Gardener
Frye
Hill
Igoudala
Jefferson
Kerr
Shakur - personal favorite
Simon
D.Stoudamire
S.Stoudamire
Terry
Walton
Woods
#BearDown
Quote from: mvpreed2 on January 25, 2026, 09:04:03 AMMy top 5, and my favorite 5 would be different
I agree with this.
In my Top 5 I included Luke Walton because I would want him as a Glue Guy, High IQ player where my team already has the scoring attributes, but would now have a second facilitator. Luke is pretty underrated. He was a NBA Head Coach for a while. His understanding of the game with Kerr, and Elliott for me is an advantage. Damon was my PG because the High Low with him and Ayton would be insane too.
Luke was extremely underrated because he was surrounded with other crazy talent like Arenas, Iggy, Frye, Salim, etc. The dude could run the point, shoot from the wing or post up...in addition to guarding every position.